| Course | PA 628 Clinical Clerkship: Elective II |
|---|---|
| Week | 1 |
| Paper type | Discussion post with two replies |
| Length | About 440 words |
| Format | Discussion post with APA 7 citations |
| School | Chamberlain University |
| Program | Master of Physician Assistant Studies (MPAS) |
| Updated | October 2026 |
Free sample paper for PA 628 Week 1
Week 1 Discussion: Initial Post
One Thing Four Weeks of Nephrology Settled for Me: Most of the Kidney Decline I Saw Was Driven by Diabetes, So My Second Elective Is the Endocrinology Clinic, and a Question Classmates Can Settle From Their Logs
The Settled Thing, Up Front
After four weeks in an outpatient nephrology clinic, one thing is settled for me: most of the kidney decline I saw was driven by diabetes, and most of the decisions that would have slowed it were made, or not made, in someone else's clinic.
Evidence From Weeks Actually Worked
Of the 20 return patients I staged for my first objective, 14 had diabetic kidney disease. In 9 of those 14, the referral letter showed an A1C above 8 percent, and in 5 the patient was not on an SGLT2 inhibitor at referral despite an eGFR of at least 20. The nephrology clinic started or continued the kidney-protecting drugs, but glucose control remained with primary care or endocrinology. Guidance for diabetes in chronic kidney disease treats these as one plan, with metformin, SGLT2 inhibitors and blood pressure control coordinated (Rossing et al., 2022), yet I watched them managed in separate rooms.
Why This Service, Said Once
My second elective is the endocrinology clinic at the same medical center, where many of the same patients are seen for their diabetes.
I chose it over a second nephrology block because the decisions I watched being deferred were glucose decisions. Staying in the kidney clinic would have taught me more about the downstream effects and nothing about the upstream choices. The endocrinology clinic is also where the insulin starts happen, and no insulin dose I have ever changed belonged to someone I would meet a second time.
A Question That Could Be Answered
For classmates who have finished a first elective: what share of the patients you saw had their main problem managed in a different clinic from yours? A rough count from your logs would do.
If the share is high for most of us, the next question is whether our training teaches the handoff between clinics at all, or only the work inside each one. I suspect the answer is the second, and I would like to be shown wrong.
Replies That Add a Case
Reply to Ines: Your cardiology elective saw heart failure. How many of those patients also had chronic kidney disease, and who was adjusting their diuretics, cardiology or nephrology?
Reply to Teo: In your dermatology elective, the psoriasis patients on biologics: did dermatology also manage their cardiovascular risk, or was that left to primary care?
References
Rossing, P., Caramori, M. L., Chan, J. C. N., Heerspink, H. J. L., Hurst, C., Khunti, K., Liew, A., Michos, E. D., Navaneethan, S. D., Olowu, W. A., Sadusky, T., Tandon, N., Tuttle, K. R., Wanner, C., Wilkens, K. G., Zoungas, S., & de Boer, I. H. (2022). KDIGO 2022 clinical practice guideline for diabetes management in chronic kidney disease. Kidney International, 102(5S), S1-S127. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.kint.2022.06.008
Reading the PA 628 Week 1 instructions
The opening post of the second elective asks you to name the completed elective by service and state one thing it settled for you, up front. Support it with evidence from the weeks you actually worked, such as counts from your log. Say once why the next service follows from it, without describing the specialty. Pose a question classmates could answer from their own logs. Replies should add a case from the classmate's own service that tests their point. If your first elective did not settle anything, say what it narrowed instead. Do not name the practice or the clinician who supervised you. The question does not have to be clinical, but it must be answerable. Cite any guidance that frames the settled point.
Inside the PA 628 Week 1 example
The post opens by stating that most kidney decline seen in four weeks of outpatient nephrology was diabetic and that the slowing decisions belonged elsewhere. The evidence section counts 14 of 20 staged patients with diabetic kidney disease, 9 referred with an A1C above 8 percent and 5 without an SGLT2 inhibitor at an eGFR of 20 or more, and cites Rossing et al. (2022) for treating the plan as one. A short section names the endocrinology clinic as the second elective. The question asks what share of each classmate's patients had their main problem managed elsewhere. Replies ask Ines who adjusted diuretics for heart failure patients with kidney disease and Teo whether dermatology managed cardiovascular risk for patients on biologics.
Where the points sit in the PA 628 Week 1 rubric
The opening of this post carries the most weight: one settled point, stated in the first lines, earns far more than a summary of the first elective. Evidence from the student's own weeks, with numbers, is weighed next. Naming the second service once, with the reason it follows, is expected; describing the specialty is not. The question is judged on whether classmates could answer it from their logs. Replies earn credit when they add a case that tests the classmate's point. Keeping supervisors and practices unnamed is required. Any guidance cited should appear in APA form.
PA 628 Week 1 help from the desk
Second elective posts tend to recap the first rotation week by week, which buries any point it settled. Another weak spot is evidence described as impressions rather than counts. Some posts also name the preceptor or site, which the assignment asks students to avoid. If your first elective settled something different, or narrowed a question without settling it, send your log counts and what changed in your thinking; we would state the point first, support it with numbers, name the next service once and end on an answerable question. Paste classmates' posts and each reply will add a case from their own service.
Get a PA-628 Week 1 example written to your instructions
Send the discussion instructions and the rubric rows your section publishes, plus a line on what your first elective actually covered, and a custom post written to them comes back inside 24-48h, the first one free. Where your section grades replies, example replies come with it, sized for a post nobody can edit once it lands.
More PA 628 papers and MPAS samples
- PA 628 Week 2: Second Choice Justification
- PA 628 Week 3: Revised Objective Set
- PA 628 Week 4: Prior Rotation Comparison
- PA 628 Week 5: Feedback Carryover Memo
- PA 628 Week 6: Specialty Interest Statement
- PA 628 Week 7: Elective Pair Synthesis
- PA 628 Week 8: Rotation Order Rationale
- PA 648 Week 1: Testable Commitment Post
- PA 626 Week 1: Elective Gap Post
- PA 650 Week 1: Practice Variation Post
- PA 624 Week 1: Chart Instruction Test Post
PA 628 Week 1 questions, answered
My first elective did not settle anything. What goes in the post?
That is usable, and it is more common than the assignment implies. Write it as a finding: the service ran narrower than expected, or the question it was chosen to answer turned out to be the wrong question. A post naming what those weeks failed to produce, and what the failure suggests about where to look now, argues a good deal more than an invented certainty does.
Can the post name the practice or the clinician who supervised me?
There is no reason to and several reasons not to. Describe the service by type and size, say what the schedule sent in, and leave out anything identifying a site, a clinician or a patient. Graders mark the reasoning rather than the roster, and a post carrying identifying detail invites a classroom discussion about material that should never have been posted at all.
Does the standing question have to be clinical?
Most sections leave that open. Questions about how a service is organized, how decisions get checked, or what the work costs the people doing it carry as well as a question about disease, and they suit an elective pair better, since a second service can answer them directly. Read your section's instructions first, because a few restrict the opening post to clinical content.
Where can I find a free PA 628 Week 1 sample paper?
This page holds a complete PA 628 Week 1 post opening the second elective with one settled point from nephrology, backed by counts.
What did the first elective settle in the PA 628 Week 1 sample?
That most of the kidney decline seen was driven by diabetes, and most of the decisions that would have slowed it were made in another clinic.